Wednesday, April 16, 2008

And the WINNER is...

Drum roll please.....


Lea Ann McCombs
Here is Lea Ann's winning First Page...

My mother died the day I was born, and my father hasn't forgiven either one of us. My childhood was shadowed by the ghost of a woman whose body may live on, but whose essence evaporated with the emergence of her firstborn child.

"It's a daughter," the nurse announced.

"Take it away," were the first words of my loving mother.

Or so I'm told through whispers and the modestly bowed heads of those who pretend to decry the telling, but who live for the opportunity.

So what is a girl to do with no one to braid her pigtails and show her how to apply lipstick?

"Not so much...That's not your shade...Let me show you how..."

I hope I don't sound bitter. The opposite is true. Bitterness is born from tortured expectations. I never had any to torture.

It was what it was. My father and I. Alone in every sense of the word. Didn't everyone's mother abandon them at birth? Didn't everyone's father mutter to himself in the darkness, drink himself into a stupor, and spend whole evenings painting sordid word pictures of what his daughter must never become?

When my mother's body healed, she packed her bags and left. No explanation that I ever heard. But in the early morning hours, when I found my father on the porch, gazing beyond the rising sun, I knew, even at the age of seven, that she had left an explanation.

At age eight, I decided I didn't care anymore why she left. She was dead to me and that was easier. I told my playmates fantastic stories of her demise which grew all the more fanciful the more I told them.

When my father found out, that was the end of the stories. And the playmates.

It was then I decided to stop living under her tombstone.

..................................................


Isn't that awesome? I want to tell you why this one came out as my #1 pick, amongst an obviously strong field of entries (as you could see from the runners-up.) The beauty is in the details. On my very first read, the line that jumped out at me immediately was "But in the early morning hours, when I found my father on the porch, gazing beyond the rising sun, I knew, even at the age of seven, that she had left an explanation." That was a huge oh-my-gosh moment for me. Powerful! This is the line that really sets up the story that's to come, and reveals a pressing "story question" that the reader (and the narrator) wants answered.

"Take it away" was perfect. Those three words said so much more. Also, “…those who pretend to decry the telling, but who live for the opportunity” shows wonderful insight into human nature, eliciting a nod of recognition from me. I liked the nice twist on the mother's "death," too.

I loved the phrase "a woman whose body may live on" in the first paragraph. The word "may" raises a question in my mind. Is the mother alive or dead? And the next phrase, "but whose essence evaporated" paints a nice word picture for me of a woman who somehow lost everything she was through the act of giving birth. This raises SO many more questions.

The best thing about this First Page is that it speaks of so much possibility for a story, and it could go many different ways, so while the reader feels like there's a good story to come, we don't feel like we already know what it is.

From this brief excerpt, I get the feeling I'd like to work with the author because there's a solid foundation of skill—terrific use of just a few words to convey an atmosphere, a style, a group of characters, and even a possible plot to come. There was a high degree of difficulty here, which also attracted me. It's not easy to capture such a complete sense of this girl's life with her father in such a few words, not easy to reveal this keen insight into human nature without sounding ponderous. This could have so easily been over-written. This is a great example of a First Page that makes me want to read more.

So CONGRATULATIONS, Lea Ann, and be sure to email me to talk about your prize.

Lea Ann, Richard, and everyone who appeared as a Finalist in Phase One or Phase Two of the Yo-Dawg-Show-Me-What-You-Got-Double-Decker-CHALLENGE... a friend of mine created these cool little banners that you can post on your blog or website, if you want. You should be able to rip them straight from here and put them wherever you want. If you have techno SKILLS, you might even include a link back to my blog (hint, hint).







Everyone else, thanks for entering and thanks for your terrific work! We'll have another contest in May... better sharpen those pencils.

26 comments:

Kim Kasch said...

That was amazing! I loved it.

Thanks for giving us all the opportunity to play along and CONGRATS! to everyone who placed, showed and WON!

Nancy I. Sanders said...

Wow and double and triple wow! Lea Ann, this has left me speechless. Congratulations everyone! And thanks, Rachelle, for lots and lots of fun!

Gwen Stewart said...

Awesome, indeed. Congrats to all!

Matthew C Jones said...

Wow, Lea Ann! Wonderful, powerful writing. I loved it! Congratulations and I hope you get to write the rest of the story.

- Matt Jones

Anonymous said...

Excellent work Lea Ann! I can't wait to read the book :).

All of the first pages were awesome and could very well become best sellers some day. Rachelle, this contest was awesome.

Thanks,
Rhonda (Rkh)

Doug said...

Lea Ann--Fabulous first page and congrats!! Have a wonderful time "discussing your prize" with Rachelle, and many blessings on your writing!

Katy McKenna www.fallible.com

Doug said...

Sometimes, if I'm not careful, I appear to be Doug, when I'm actually always Katy.... :)

Katy McKenna www.fallible.com

Richard Mabry said...

Lea Ann--excellent writing. I can see why it was chosen.

To everyone who entered--it was fun. Thanks for sharing your lines and openings.

Rachelle--thanks for the opportunity to "play." I've copied the image, and as soon as I figure out how to do it, I'll put it on my own blog. As for a link to your site, you're already on my sidebar but I'll put a hyperlink with this story.

Mark H. said...

Congratulations Richard and Lea Ann! This is great stuff. What a fun experience this has been!

Catherine Downen said...

Wow! Lea Ann your writing takes my breath away! So artfully, masterfully written. You have a great talent, a gift. Rachelle, thank you so much for this contest.

Pam Halter said...

Wonderful! What a heart tug. I do want to read more. Congrats, Lea Ann ~ you have a beautiful way of weaving your words.

Catherine West said...

This would rank up in my collection of 'readable' first person. I rarely enjoy reading anything written in first, which means these days I'm not finding much to read.
:0) It's just a strange quirk I have I guess. I won't go as far as to call it an eccentricity...I'm not that old yet!
If I do buy a book written in first, I can usually tell by the end of the first page whether or not I'll finish it.
It has to grab my attention and pull me into the story in such a way that I forget I'm reading in first and just read.
Lea Ann, I will finish this book when it is published.

Brenners said...

Wonderful, Lee Ann! You certainly do a marvelous job making every words count.

Thanks, Rachelle, for the opportunity to join in the fun. It was a good learning experience.

Brenners said...

edit: "...making every word count."

Amy Storms said...

Great job, Lee Ann. Congratulations!

Ed J. Horton said...

Congratulations to Lea Ann and Richard, and the other finalists. Besides enticing your readers, you've proven a lot can be said--about character, setting, plot--in the opening page.

I look forward to the May contest, Rachelle. Thanks for all you do to further the writing of budding authors!

Robbie Iobst said...

Lea Ann, Wow! I am so intrigued and really want to read the book now. Congratulations!

Rachelle, After resting up...wait, do you rest up? Anyway, how's about a YO-DAWG nonfiction challenge sometime...hmmm. Something to think about.

david w. fry said...

What a tremendous blessing this has been! Rachelle, you have brought to life the equivalent of an online 'master class' and we as students are benefiting from a unique perspective .. that of an agent in action.

Thank you for sharing a bit of the mystery of the process. This helps all of us get a grip on the reality of the industry.

Now then, we have a better understanding of what drives the "pass" letters we receive after submitting our work in the real.

I use the idea of "pass letter" versus rejection letter because I like to think that the work that was submitted has been "passed over" - this helps distance one from the emotional force of "rejection" and maintains a professional distance.

The "pass" then becomes a challenging motivator! Or, being a newbie to the craft, I may just be too naive to know the difference. :-)

I DO know that this exercise has been immensely worthwhile.

And to those finalists and winners who were not passed over ... celebrate! We are celebrating with you and we soldier on.

Or as a friend of mine is want to say: "Continue with vigor!"

Anonymous said...

Thank you to all you who are leaving such kind comments! A special thanks to Christa Allan for creating such an intriguing first line to work with! And thanks again, Rachelle, for giving us this forum to learn.
Lea Ann McCombs

Kathryn Harris said...

Great writing! I love the emotions it stirs.

But do we have to wait until May for another contest? This was fun. I want to do it (or something similar) again. ;-)

Jennifer L. Griffith said...

WOW, wow, WOW!!

I agree, Rachelle. Now that's intriguing, indeed.

Congratulations Lea Ann!!

Debbie said...

I have goose bumps! You are a gifted writer with a great deal of perception. I have a feeling we've all gotten a peek at something big.

Debbie

cballan said...

Lea Ann:
What a poignant and masterful story. You have a gift. I'm looking forward to reading what comes next and next and next. Seeing my first line open such a well-crafted and beautifully phrased story delighted me. If you ever need more first lines, I'll be happy to oblige if they all lead to such wonder!

Kara said...

Wow! Congratulations Lea Ann - amazing job.

Randy Mortenson said...

This is really, really good. Congratulations and blessings, Lea Ann.

Tiffany Stuart said...

Lea Ann, well said. LOVE it!

Thanks, Rachelle, for bringing writers together for a fun contest!